AEW’s long-building storyline featuring MJF and The Hurt Syndicate continues to receive praise for its suspenseful pacing, layered character work, and unpredictability. During a recent episode of Busted Open, hosts Dave LaGreca and Nic Nemeth broke down why this narrative has become essential weekly viewing for wrestling fans.
The ongoing angle revolves around whether or not MJF will be officially accepted into the faction led by Bobby Lashley. The storytelling has revolved around subtle but powerful moments—particularly Lashley’s dramatic “thumbs up/thumbs down” teases. “That’s how you book a wrestling show,” Nemeth said, applauding AEW for creating weekly cliffhangers that keep fans guessing.
LaGreca highlighted the misdirection involving Shelton Benjamin nearly turning on MJF, which added a layer of tension to the faction’s dynamic. “You don’t know if they’re going to hug him or beat his ass,” he said. “And that’s what makes this story compelling. There’s a real sense of danger and unpredictability.”
Rather than rushing the payoff, AEW has allowed the story to unfold slowly, drawing fans in each week with teases, tension, and small reveals. It’s a departure from the more match-heavy, resolution-focused format the company often leans on. “This is one of my favorite things AEW is doing right now,” Nemeth added. “And I’m actually looking forward to next week—and that’s what wrestling should do.”
If you use any portion of the quotes from this article please credit Busted Open Radio with a h/t to WrestlingNews.co for the transcription.
